U.S. District Court Overturns Companionship Exemption Rule Changes

Stephen Tweed | December 23, 2014 | Newsroom
The Home Care  Association of America and  The National Association for Home Care and Hospice announced today that the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia has ruled in their favor in the case regarding the Companionship Exemption Overtime Rule.  The rule, by Judge Richard J. Leon, grants the plaintiffs' motion and vacates the…

The Home Care  Association of America and  The National Association for Home Care and Hospice announced today that the U.S. District Court for the District of HCAOA vs David WeilColumbia has ruled in their favor in the case regarding the Companionship Exemption Overtime Rule.  The rule, by Judge Richard J. Leon, grants the plaintiffs’ motion and vacates the U.S. Department of Labor’s efforts to deny third party employers access to the exemption under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA).

The Department’s rule set to take effect on January 1, 2015, would have prevented home care companies from using the companionship exemption to avoid paying overtime.  The lawsuit challenged that rule.

According to Judge Leon’s ruling, “The language of the exemption is quite clear: ‘any employee’ who is employed to provide companionship services, or who resides in the household in which he or she is employed to perform domestic services, is covered by the exemption.”

The plaintiffs in the case are seeking a hold on the rule while other portions of the lawsuit are being considered.  While this is a huge win for the home care community, they believe an appeal will be filed by the DOL, so the fight is not over.

Here is a link to the Judge’s Ruling.  

Stay tuned to Private Duty Today and Leading Home Care Report for updates on the status of this lawsuit and the implementation of the DOL rule.
Stephen Tweed
Stephen Tweed is among the top Thought Leaders in Home Care today. As an industry researcher, author, and executive coach, he has worked with owners and CEOs of companies in the top 5% of Home Care and is a frequent speaker at Home Care association conferences and corporate meetings across the US and Canada.

Related Posts

The Top Five Applications of AI in Home Care

March 12, 2026
We recently surveyed over 320 Home Care agency Founders, Owners, and CEOs as part of the 2026 Future of Home Care Study, conducted by Leading Home Carean published by AxisCare. From last year's survey we found that many Home Care leaders are looking at the possibilities for AI in their businesses, so this year we dug more deeply into…

All That Jazz

March 5, 2026
Last night we attended a terrific jazz concert at Artis-Naples, the museum and performance venue here in Naples Florida. My wife, Elizabeth Jeffries, and I really enjoy the music here. Last night's performance featured Gary Smulyan, Grammy winning Baritone Saxophonist leading a six-piece ensemble. As the band moved through their set, Elizabeth leaned over and whispered, "Look at their faces.…

Finding and Keeping Caregivers

February 26, 2026
In January, we published the 2026 Future of Home Care Study, conducted by Leading Home Care ... a Tweed Jeffries company, and sponsored by AxisCare. This is the third year for this industry-leading research, and we captured some very interesting new data and information. However, one thing is not new. The biggest pain points for Home Care CEOs for…